CALL ME (24/7) 1-877-212-9645
The police attended the client’s home near Nakusp, BC to check on the well being of a woman that the police had received concerning phone calls about.  While standing at the front door to the residence, the police officer was able to speak with the woman and determine that she was fine, however while standing at the door he smelled the odour of what he referred to as “vegetative marihuana”.  The officer returned to the police station and drafted an Information to Obtain (“ITO”) a search warrant for the house on the basis of the smell of marihuana.  The next day the police executed the warrant and discovered a modestly sized indoor marihuana grow operation.  The client as well as two other people living in the house were charged with production of marihuana and possession for the purpose of trafficking.  At trial Mr. van der Walle argued that the grounds set out out by the officer in the ITO were insufficient and did not give rise to reasonable and probable grounds, which is the standard that needs to be met to obtain a search warrant.  Specifically, the officer had failed to set out his experience and how he is able to reliably distinguish between the odour of growing marihuana plants versus the odour of dried “bud” marihuana and the odour of smoked marihuana.  After hearing argument the Supreme Court Judge agreed with the defence and ruled that the warrant was invalid.  At that point the prosecutor, much to his credit, decided that it was likely that the illegally obtained evidence would be excluded and opted to drop the charges.  Not guilty.  Client did not testify.

Archives

Related Stories

The Queen v. H.(A.) 2019

In Kelowna, after the belated Canada Day fireworks, an experienced police officer was heading back to the detachment to finish off his shift and saw the client's vehicle pull out of a gravel parking lot.  The officer decided to randomly stop the vehicle to check...

read more

The Queen v. C.(I.) 2019

The Merritt police were called by a woman who said that her ex husband was "drunk as a skunk" and pounding on the front door in the middle of the night.  The police arrived and found the client passed out in the driver seat of his vehicle.  The vehicle was still...

read more

The Queen v. B.(D.) 2019

The police observed the client meet with a well known and high level drug trafficker  for a short amount of time.  They then followed the client and watched him make three short duration meets in downtown Vernon.  The client was arrested and taken to the police...

read more

REQUEST A FREE CONSULTATION

Call 1.877.212.9645

Or fill out the form below to receive a free and confidential initial consultation.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.